Man Who Killed Girlfriend with Hammer and Left Her in Mother Goose-Themed Park 'Sold Soul to Devil': Judge

Mar. 15, 2025

Sean Goe and Raychel Sheridan.Photo:Stark County Sheriff’s Office

Stark County Sheriff’s Office

An Ohio man convicted of killing his girlfriend with a hammer and dumping her body in an abandoned Mother Goose-themed park was sentenced to 29 years to life in prison.

On Friday, Nov. 8, Sean Goe, 27, of Plain Township, was found guilty of murder, felonious assault, gross abuse of a corpse and tampering with evidence in the murder of Raychel Sheridan, 24, court records show.

On Monday, Goe appeared in the Stark County Courthouse in Canton where Stark County Common Pleas Court Judge Frank Forchione handed down the sentence along with some harsh words regarding the crime.

“Mr. Goe, you sold your soul to the devil," Judge Forchione said,News 5 Clevelandreports. “I have ordered you to receive the maximum sentence on every count because you deserve the maximum sentence.”

Forchione added that it is “without a doubt, the most brutal murder that I’ve seen.”

Goe sat in silence as the judge called him “morally bankrupt” with “no fiber of decency,”WKYCreported.

“Displaying the lowest level for human life, you then wrapped the body in a sheet and dumped it in a park near Mother Goose Land,” Forchione said. This is the person that at one point you claimed that you were in love with. Instead, you threw her in the trash like a piece of garbage.”

Prosecutors said she was beaten with the blunt end of a hammer that was recovered inside the apartment Sheridan shared with Goe,The Canton Repositoryreports.

Sheridan suffered at least 10 blows to the head, Dennis E. Barr, chief of the criminal division of the Stark County Prosecutor’s Office, said in his closing remarks at the trial, according toThe Canton Repository.

Prosecutors said she was beaten with the blunt end of a hammer that was recovered inside the apartment Sheridan shared with Goe,The Canton Repositoryreported.

The crime came to light on July 3, when a Canton Parks Department employee found Sheridan’s body wrapped in plastic inside a garbage can at Mother Goose Land on Schroyer Ave. SW, according to anews release from the Stark County Sheriff’s Office.

The day before, Sheridan’s mother called police to perform a welfare check on her at the apartment she shared with Goe when she hadn’t heard from her and reported her missing, according to the news release from the Sheriff’s Office.

When Stark County Sheriff deputies arrived at the apartment, the door was open, but no one was inside. However, what they saw inside looked suspicious, police said, per19 News.

Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up forPEOPLE’s free True Crime newsletterfor breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.

Deputies then requested a search warrant, but while they waited for it, they saw what they believed to be Sheridan’s maroon Jeep Liberty driving down the street with Goe behind the wheel, the release said.

“As a result of the search warrant executed at the apartment of Raychel Sheridan and Sean Goe, evidence was recovered indicating foul play,” the release noted, adding, “Detectives have determined that Sheridan was murdered inside the apartment."

In August, Goe was indicted on two counts of murder and single counts of felonious assault, burglary, tampering with evidence, grand theft of a firearm or dangerous ordnance and gross abuse of a corpse, according toonline court records. He was held on a $1 million bond and pleaded not guilty.

Goe will be eligible for parole after 29 years in prison. PEOPLE reached out to his public defender for comment, but they did not immediately respond.

source: people.com